'Lights out' plan for Exeter prompts protests

Profile image for Exeter Express and Echo

By Exeter Express and Echo | Thursday, September 06, 2012, 06:45

CONCERNS are growing over plans to switch off streetlights overnight across the city.

Devon County Council is spending £1.7m on technology which will allow it to switch off or dim the lights in residential areas between 12.30am and 5am.

It plans to introduce the measure in Exeter next spring in a bid to save £138,000 and up to 1,600 tonnes of carbon annually by turning off 10,000 of the city's 14,000 lights.

Main road lighting and areas of high night-time activity, such as the city centre, will remain lit all night, though they could occasionally be dimmed.

But residents' groups, students and councillors have expressed concerns about the plan and claim there has been no proper consultation.

City students say they are making it their number one priority to prevent the switch-off because of fears over safety.

Grace Hopper, the Guild of Students' vice-president for welfare and community, said: "The council's plans to switch off our streetlights after minimal consultation with the public is not just a huge concern for safety-conscious students, but the residents of Exeter as a whole.

"Many routes that students use on a regular basis will be heavily affected, in which case there will undoubtedly be unease and anxiety.

"I will be heading up the Save Our Streetlights (SOS) campaign to raise awareness of the council's proposed plan."

She added: "Over the following months I will work closely with members of the community, so that residents as well as students have their say in such an important issue.

"Together, I believe we can save our streetlights, and send a message to the council that the welfare of those travelling at night is not an issue open to debate."

Michael Parrott, of Newtown Community Association, said: "Due to the close proximity to the city centre and nightclubs, a number of people do walk through Newtown to get home late at night and in the early hours of the morning and therefore I certainly feel that at least some areas should remain lit."

Members of Polsloe Community Association also have concerns and the issue has been put on the agenda for its next meeting in October.

Richard Westlake, county councillor for Polsloe and Newtown said: "Devon County Council has not consulted in our area at all – the only consultation they have done has been in Pinhoe. The whole process is being done in a very amateurish way. At the moment residents and councillors are confused as to what is happening."

Polsloe city councillor Yolonda Henson said: "The problems with anti-social behaviour is when the clubs come out – and that's when the lights will be out. The problems will not necessarily be in the city centre but in the roads through which students are walking home. I am worried about this and believe it will cost us in the end – what is saved in energy costs will cost in terms of anti-social behaviour and is going to be thrown on to the police."

Councillor Pete Edwards, leader of the city council, said the county should call meetings specifically to consult residents on the issue.

Superintendent Jim Gale, responsible for policing in Exeter, Mid and East Devon said: "We would be constantly monitoring it and if we felt the risk of being a victim had risen we would look at things such as increased patrols or more lighting."

A spokesman for Devon County Council said there has been no rise in crime in parts of Devon which have already introduced the scheme, including Exmouth in 2010, and said there would be more consultation in Exeter. He said: "We know there will be concerns from some areas of the city, and that's what we're hoping to get a feel for from the consultation, before final decisions about the detail are made."



  • Profile image for mallorcasaint

    As an astronomer I would love to see the night sky without the light pollution caused by sodium lighting. I do, however understand the concerns about safety. The solution is to invest in modern environmentally efficient lighting which uses less power and is directed downwards where it is actually needed! Most street lighting is inefficient and light leaks into the sky and blots out everything. We should be looking at installing LED based street lights which would save money in the long term.

    By mallorcasaint at 14:03 on 18/09/12

  • Profile image for McSquittersly

    "How the world survived before street lighting" - yes because Victorian/Edwardian/Medival streets are famously know for their warmth, enlightened atmosphere and complete safety after dark. More patronising, bourgeosie trolling on these messaging boards destroying any sense of debate. You win, well done.

    By McSquittersly at 15:45 on 09/09/12

  • Profile image for JCC12

    Having read all of these comments I have a strong urge to correct some of the bizarre presumptions and underline some of the major issues here....
    - Firstly 'Ladybugs', I'm glad you enjoy your rural setting and the naturally low crime figures (I can almost hear the 'archers' themetune), but were talking about the impact of switchoffs in the city of Exeter. I would even say that the Exmouth example is in no way a fair or direct comparison either.
    - Even if the the impact on crime is low (which I seriously doubt) FEAR of crime is a real and genuine issue. And, I would point out, that reductions in the fear of crime is a Police priority too.
    - This, of course, IS NOT just a student issue - a point highlighted by the student in this piece. The truth is that student groups were merely the FIRST to speak up about the potential impact of switchoffs, well done students for speaking up first - unlike the armchair pontificators who spew their cliched, tiresome and 'inherited' views on sites such as this.
    - On the bizarre student/council tax angle...this really does exasperate me. Tax payers DO NOT cover council tax payments for those who are not in full employment (including students, but not just students) - and the city is directly reimbursed by central govt. for council tax lost. In short, no one loses out. In fact, some would argue that the City 'do quite well' from this arrangement and, as an ex-council employee I really do urge someone to do a freedom of info. request on how much is gleaned and what it is spent on...but thats another debate.
    - I'd also just like to say how depressed I am that, as a society, we appear perfectly happy to accept the FEAR of switchoffs as a way to achieve a sense of 'order' in our streets. George Orwell eat your heart out...
    - lastly, as an ex council employee - beware of any council response that states they're happy to consult on the 'detail'. This is another way of saying 'Its a done deal folks'....I for one will be joining in with the petition...

    By JCC12 at 11:44 on 09/09/12

  • Profile image for 2ladybugs

    Makes you wonder how the world ever survived before street lighting was invented.

    By 2ladybugs at 12:52 on 08/09/12

  • Profile image for TheGreenMan

    Re: "lights out" plan for Exeter. This is a tricky question, as can be seen from the large number of comments that the article has drawn. While I applaud the carbon reduction, in Exmouth, as aridgers has said, "there has been a rise in fear and frustration when all the lights black out precisely at 1am". Certainly you need to be prepared with a torch, etc, if you're out in Exmouth late, while cycling in the blackout is not recommended. I feel the move works OK-ish residential areas, but is less suitable for town and especially city centres.

    By TheGreenMan at 20:07 on 07/09/12

max 4000 characters

Latest Stories in Exmouth


Local Vouchers


Local Jobs


Search for...

Min price is bigger than Max price
Min price is bigger than Max price
Min rent is bigger than Max rent